MB Pro Behaves Rudely with Low Battery

One of my MB Pro's, a 15", shuts down without ceremony or warning when the battery level reaches 30%.
Walter Bushell wrote on :

In article 260220090024589628%nospam@redacted.invalid, nospam nospam@redacted.invalid wrote:

In article 250220092330344302%star@redacted.invalid, Davoud star@redacted.invalid wrote:

One of my MB Pro's, a 15", shuts down without ceremony or warning when the battery level reaches 30%. The machine issues a quiet click, the screen goes black, and it's off.

sounds like the battery may have a defective cell. what happens if you put that battery in a different mbp and a known good battery in the problem mbp?

Or needs to be re-calibrated. But check the battery in the About this Mac->More Info->Hardware->Power->Battery

nospam replied on :

In article proto-48F941.10535125032009@redacted.invalid, Walter Bushell proto@redacted.invalid wrote:

One of my MB Pro's, a 15", shuts down without ceremony or warning when the battery level reaches 30%. The machine issues a quiet click, the screen goes black, and it's off.

sounds like the battery may have a defective cell. what happens if you put that battery in a different mbp and a known good battery in the problem mbp?

Or needs to be re-calibrated. But check the battery in the About this Mac->More Info->Hardware->Power->Battery

sudden shutdown is almost always due to a defective cell. as the pack is discharged, the bad cell reverses polarity which causes the voltage of the entire pack to drop below the minimum needed to run the computer, thus it simply shuts off without warning.

Simon Slavin replied on :

In article 250220092330344302%star@redacted.invalid Davoud star@redacted.invalid wrote:

One of my MB Pro's, a 15", shuts down without ceremony or warning when the battery level reaches 30%. The machine issues a quiet click, the screen goes black, and it's off.

Defective battery. Get the battery replaced. It happened to me.