PowerBook battery - Can this be right!?

Secondly, the replacement battery isn't just a battery, it's a whole USB port and battery assembly
Ian Cargill wrote on :

So, my four year old G4 Powerbook (17 inch Alluminium) has started to revert to that date (is it 1901?) which lets me know that its internal back up battery needs replaced.

Thinking that a replacement would cost about five quid - no, ten quid, this is a Mac! - and be readily available at my local Maplins, I had a quick look on the net to see what I needed.

Well, first off, these things are surprisingly thin on the ground. http://www.applemacparts.co.uk/store/ seems to be one of the very few sources for a replacement battery. You'd think they would be in the Applestore. I mean, shouldn't there be hundreds of thousands of aging PowerBooks with depleted batteries by now!?

Secondly, the replacement battery isn't just a battery, it's a whole USB port and battery assembly (see http://www.applemacparts.co.uk/store/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=35 2&products_id=63133 ). And it doesn't cost 10, it's 65 + VAT + Shipping. That's over 80!

To add insult to injury, it seems that much of the PowerBook has to be disassembled in order to fit the thing - torque screwdrivers, ribbns disconnected, the lot!

Rant over. Starting to feel a bit better!

Ian

David Kennedy replied on :

On 28/1/08 09:50, Ian Cargill wrote:

So, my four year old G4 Powerbook (17 inch Alluminium) has started to revert to that date (is it 1901?) which lets me know that its internal back up battery needs replaced.

Thinking that a replacement would cost about five quid - no, ten quid, this is a Mac! - and be readily available at my local Maplins, I had a quick look on the net to see what I needed.

Well, first off, these things are surprisingly thin on the ground. http://www.applemacparts.co.uk/store/ seems to be one of the very few sources for a replacement battery. You'd think they would be in the Applestore. I mean, shouldn't there be hundreds of thousands of aging PowerBooks with depleted batteries by now!?

Secondly, the replacement battery isn't just a battery, it's a whole USB port and battery assembly (see http://www.applemacparts.co.uk/store/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=35 2&products_id=63133 ). And it doesn't cost 10, it's 65 + VAT + Shipping. That's over 80!

To add insult to injury, it seems that much of the PowerBook has to be disassembled in order to fit the thing - torque screwdrivers, ribbns disconnected, the lot!

US$80 from ifixit.com so 80 quid is about right...

Why not fit a larger HD while you're in there!

Ian Cargill replied on :

In article ian-834250.09533828012008@redacted.invalid, Ian Cargill ian@redacted.invalid wrote:

So, my four year old G4 Powerbook (17 inch Alluminium) has started to revert to that date (is it 1901?) which lets me know that its internal back up battery needs replaced. snip . And it doesn't cost 10, it's 65 + VAT + Shipping. That's over 80!

I've just ordered a replacement for the main battery of the PowerBook (the original lasted about an hour on full charge and, if left for a couple of days, drained completely which I suppose accellerated the death of the internal PRAM battery!). It's a non-Apple battery, mind you, but it cost only 36 all in, including shipping. That's less than half the cost of the PRAM battery. It seems perverse!

Ian